Law Office of John W. Noonan
925-463-3340 Call For A Free Initial Consultation Se Habla Español Available 24/7

When fines as a criminal penalty are inequitably distributed

What is wrong with what a recent New York Times opinion piece terms "one-size-fits-all fines" in criminal law cases?

In a word, plenty.

As that article notes, a penalty that is precisely the same for all offenders (a fixed-amount ticket for a driving-related infraction, for example) might be nothing more than a slight wrist slap for one individual, while spelling near financial disaster for another.

That's not fair.

And fairness -- that is, evenhanded and impartial enforcement outcomes doled out to all criminal defendants -- is something that state and federal laws across the United States must be unwaveringly focused on at all times to ensure integrity in the justice system. That lacks when, say, a speeding ticket equates to nothing more than pocket change to one person while simultaneously bankrupting another.

The above-cited article notes a central irony that looms large whenever all persons convicted of a crime must shell out the same amount of cash in atonement.

And that is this: Although that seems facially fair, financial reality actually makes it the epitome of unfairness. It can only be justified, notes the Times commentator, "if you ignore the consequences of a fine on the life of the person paying it.

If you hang with Bill Gates, five grand out the window following a DUI conviction is peanuts. If you're living in hand-to-mouth mode, it can destroy your life.

That discrepancy -- which reveals itself over and over across California and the rest of the country -- flips core criminal law concepts like punishment and deterrence on their heads. For one demographic (the ultra wealthy), a case outcome can be virtually irrelevant in its triviality. For another (candidly, the poor), the same result can "destabilize lives."

That disparity needs to be eliminated by a more equitable process that links punishment to a person's actual income, asserts the Times piece. Until it is, flat fines will "deter the wealthy less than everyone else."

Recent Case Results

  • Drunk Driving Offenses

    John was able to get client a reduction of charge of a DUI because of being a nurse it could mean her license.

    He secured a Drunk in Public , and she would attend a 3 month program. Additionally, the dmv hearing was also set aside.

    Both being a win for the client.

    Read More
  • Domestic Violence

    A client was arrested for a Felony Domestic Violence, could have devastated her potential for future employment. John was able to get the case dismissed. Client was thrilled.

    Read More
  • Juvenile Charges

    A juvenile was arrested for 2nd Degree Robbery. After 6 months the case was dismissed.

    A juvenile was arrested for Sexual Battery. After 6 months and 80 hours of Community service, the case was dismissed.

    Read More
  • Drunk Driving Offenses

    A client with a 1st DUI arrest. Fearing she would go to jail; lose her license for a year and lose her job. Got a wet reckless and minimal fines.

    Read More
  • Drug Charges

    A client with 4 Felony charges on a Transportation Charge, a Attempt to Sell, Possession of Marijuana, (50 pounds), Conspiracy Charge all where reduced to 1 Misdemeanor. No Jail.

    Client was charged with 6 Felony drug possessions. Facing jail time. The results: Client got a deferred entry of judgment and then dismissed.

    Client charged with several felony counts of possession of Marijuana with intent to sell. Client was involved in a medical marijuana grow. Case was reduced and later dismissed.

    Read More
  • Sex Crimes

    A client with alleged 2 Felony Sex charges and he faced jail and sex registration. The case was entirely dismissed.

    Client charged with prostitution; facing jail time and sex offender registration. Result: NO JAIL TIME AND NO SEX OFFENDER REGISTRATION Deferred Entry of Judgment.

    Read More
  • Domestic Violence

    Client charged with domestic violence, with great bodily injury. Case reduced to a misdemeanor with time served.

    Read More
Email Us For A Response

Learn How We Can Help

Contact Information

Areas We Serve

Dublin Office
6379 Clark Avenue
Suite 250
Dublin, CA 94568

Phone: 925-463-3340
Fax: 925-479-0015
Dublin Law Office Map

Manteca Office
210 East Center Street
Suite 10
Manteca, CA 95336

Phone: 925-463-3340
Fax: 925-479-0015
Manteca Law Office Map

Back To Top